You may have heard the old adage “measure twice and cut once”. Scientists take this concept to the extreme, so the saying would be more like: “measure 50 times, then calculate the average and determine the possible uncertainty. Next cut a cheap piece of cardboard to the average size and test to make sure that it fits first, then finally cut the board. After you put the board in place, evaluate the goodness of fit, then think about how you could get an even better fit next time. Oh yeah, and write everything down along the way so you or anyone else can come along and follow the same process every time.” You might not make 50 measurements in your everyday life, but you can still use the concepts of error, precision, accuracy, and uncertainty to save yourself time, energy, and trouble.
Tyler recently had an eye exam and his prescription changed. He has decided to order his new eyeglasses online to save money. He can upload a photo of his prescription, but he needs to provide his pupil distance, or PD and this is not written on the prescription. This is a common problem so the company website has a video explaining that PD is the distance between your pupils, measured in millimeters (mm) and showing how to measure PD using a ruler and a mirror.
Measuring pupil distance with a mirror. Image Credit: “Expert Reviewed How to Measure Your Interpupillary Distance” by WikiHow
Tyler tries the measurement and finds that the ruler is pretty far below his pupil and his pupil is several mm wide, so it’s hard to line up the edge of the ruler with the center of one pupil and it’s also hard to tell which mark on the ruler lines up best with the center of his other pupil. Even worse, his eye and the ruler both move a bit during the measurement. Tyler doesn’t want to get his PD wrong and have to hassle with sending the glasses back.
Tyler makes several measurements and gets 56 mm, 57 mm, and 54 mm and he is uncertain of the actual value. He decides that because the marks on the ruler are plenty close together that piece of equipment isn’t affecting his precision much. Instead, he decides his method is the culprit.
Tyler considers making a mark on his face just below one pupil that he can use to line up the edge of the ruler. After thinking more about it, Tyler realizes that if his mark wasn’t perfect then this would introduce a systematic error into the measurement.
Instead, Tyler decides to ignore the precision issue and focus on getting an accurate result. He thinks it’s likely that the difficulty in lining up the ruler makes his measurement sometimes too short and sometimes too long, so he decides to make a few more measurements and average all of the results. He makes four more measurements, getting 56 mm, 55 mm, 57 mm and 58 mm. Then he takes the average of all seven results:
The website for ordering glasses only let Tyler enter whole mm values, so he had to decide between 56 mm or 57 mm. Tyler’s calculated average was closer to 56 mm so he entered that along with his prescription.
- "Expert Reviewed How to Measure Your Interpupillary Distance" by WikiHow is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 3.0↵